Milkshake Haven: Top 12 Must-Visit Places on Hilton Head Island

Hilton Head Ice Cream, a long-standing shop on Hilton Head Island, is a must-visit for milkshake enthusiasts. With a wide variety of tasty and creamy ice cream choices, guests are sure to find a flavor that tickles their taste buds. Not only that, but the staff at Hilton Head Ice Cream are known for their friendliness and efficiency, ensuring a pleasant and quick service experience.

This family-friendly ice cream shop also caters to those with dietary restrictions, as they have all flavors listed with allergies including egg, dairy, nut, and gluten allergies. The only drawback is that the only seating available is outdoors, but the nice sitting area makes up for it.

Visitors highly recommend this place and often return during their vacation, emphasizing the quality of the ice cream and the pleasant atmosphere. So, if you find yourself on Hilton Head Island, don't miss the chance to satisfy your milkshake cravings at Hilton Head Ice Cream.

---

The Ice Cream Cone is a storied, family-owned deli/parlor that is well worth visiting for its delectable milkshakes. With an extensive selection of flavors, guests rave about the wide variety to choose from. People say that the lines in the evening can get long, but they typically move quickly, ensuring that you won't have to wait too long for your sweet treat.

Reviewers particularly enjoyed the Graham Central Station and Peanut Butter Cookie Dough flavors. Indoor seating is available for those looking to enjoy their milkshakes in a cozy and comfortable environment. However, parking can be a bit of a challenge.

Despite this, visitors praise the friendly and attentive staff, making it a delightful experience from start to finish. One reviewer even expressed their love for the ice cream, stating that they visited every day of their honeymoon and considered it the best ice cream ever.

They were impressed by the smooth texture and top-tier flavors, with the dark chocolate raspberry truffle being their absolute favorite. Another guest was delighted by the personal touch of the owner, Pete, who not only served them with utmost politeness but also shared his fascinating collection of fossils on the wall.

This attention to detail and customer interaction left a lasting impression, with the reviewer giving a perfect rating and eagerly looking forward to their next visit.

---

Cook Out is a local fast-food restaurant that is well worth visiting in Hilton Head Island, SC. People say the staff at this location is fast and efficient, making the drive-thru experience a breeze. The food is reasonably priced, and many guests recommend trying their plate, which offers a variety of delicious options.

The char-grilled burger is particularly tasty, and the chicken nuggets platter, complete with hush puppies and onion rings, receives high praise. However, the standout item on the menu is definitely their oreo milkshake, described by visitors as amazing.

Cook Out is a great chain with affordable prices that will satisfy any milkshake enthusiast. Although some reviewers were disappointed by the lack of dine-in options and long drive-thru lines, they still appreciated the quality of the food and the excellent service.

The only minor issue mentioned by guests was a mistake with the drink size. Despite these small setbacks, Cook Out remains a must-visit spot for milkshake lovers in Hilton Head Island.

---

The Salty Dog Ice Cream Shop is a local favorite for indulging in delicious milkshakes. This classic American ice cream shop offers a menu filled with comfort food and refreshing drinks in a traditional setting. Visitors often mention that while the lines may be long, they move quickly, ensuring a minimal wait for their milkshake fix.

People rave about the variety of flavors available, with favorites including the strawberry oreo, butter pecan, and cake batter shakes. Additionally, guests mention that The Salty Dog Ice Cream Shop also serves fantastic root beer floats, making it a must-visit spot.

Another advantage is that this establishment is not just an ice cream shop, but also features stores and a café, creating a fun and lively atmosphere. One reviewer advises that the ice cream factory is located on the other side of the café, prompting guests to park at the far end of the parking lot for a shorter walk.

So, if you're in South Beach and looking for a perfect milkshake, don't miss out on the delicious offerings at The Salty Dog Ice Cream Shop.

---

Cinnamon Bear Country Store, located in Hilton Head Island, is a worthy stop for anyone seeking the best milkshakes on the island. Visitors rave about the amazing ice cream and wonderful service they receive at this charming store. One guest mentioned getting a triple scoop for their three kids to split, and were pleasantly surprised by the generous portion sizes.

Not only that, but the staff even provided extra bowls so each child could have their own. Another guest mentioned the reasonably priced ice cream scoops, which also come with free toppings, making it a great value for the area. Additionally, the store offers a multitude of various items and candies, adding to the overall fun and enjoyable experience.

Despite the parking challenge, guests highly recommend Cinnamon Bear Country Store for their delicious ice cream options, including the highly recommended Bourbon Pecan flavor. It's important not to confuse this spot with the Harbour Town General Store, as they are two distinct establishments.

---

Kilwins Hilton Head Shelter Cove is a favorite among visitors for its exceptional milkshakes and sweet treats. With its traditional store selling chocolates, confections, fudge, and original recipe ice cream, Kilwins is always a reliable choice, according to people's reviews.

The owner, Max, is praised for his friendly and helpful demeanor, providing excellent customer service. Despite occasional waiting lines, guests assure that the wait is well worth it, as the staff is readily available to answer any questions about their wide selection of ice cream flavors and toppings.

Kilwins is known for its delectable chocolate shakes, which come generously layered with a pound of creamy ice cream. While some guests mention the higher price of $14 per shake, they emphasize the outstanding quality that justifies the expense. Visitors also appreciate the opportunity to witness the in-house production of homemade waffle cones, adding to the charm of the experience.

Furthermore, Kilwins offers an array of other homemade candies that guests can enjoy alongside their indulgent milkshakes.

---

Located in Hilton Head Island, Frozen Moo is a family-owned dessert parlor that offers an impressive selection of over 90 flavors of ice cream, frozen yogurt, and sorbet. Visitors consistently rave about the quality and taste of the milkshakes at Frozen Moo, making it a must-visit spot for any milkshake enthusiast.

People say that the hot fudge sundae with chocolate fudge ice cream is a standout option, with the ice cream being incredibly smooth, creamy, and full of flavor. Additionally, guests appreciate the exceptional customer service provided by the staff. One reviewer recounted an incident where their three-year-old accidentally dropped their ice cream cone outside the shop, and one of the employees immediately brought them a replacement without even being asked.

This act of kindness left a lasting impression on the reviewer and made their experience even more enjoyable. The dedication and efficiency of the staff is also frequently mentioned, with multiple visitors praising their ability to handle a busy shop while maintaining a positive attitude.

With its extensive flavor choices and exceptional service, Frozen Moo is a top contender for the best milkshake in Hilton Head Island.

---

With its charming atmosphere and delectable offerings, Wayback Burgers is a hidden gem for milkshake enthusiasts. The restaurant has gained a devoted following, with visitors raving about their mouthwatering milkshakes. People say that the extensive menu caters to all tastes, with a variety of flavors that will leave guests spoilt for choice.

The shakes are made using premium ingredients, ensuring a rich and creamy texture that is second to none. Guests particularly praise the generous serving sizes, making it the perfect spot for those looking to satisfy their milkshake cravings. The friendly and attentive staff add to the overall experience, providing exceptional service that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Additionally, the comfortable seating arrangements and inviting ambiance provide the ideal setting to indulge in these heavenly treats. Whether it's a classic vanilla or an innovative creation like their famous Cookie Butter shake, Wayback Burgers is the ultimate destination for milkshake enthusiasts.

---

Gr8 Bites, a quaint ice-cream shop and confectionery, is definitely worth a visit when in Hilton Head Island. Tucked away from the main road, guests say it is well worth the effort to find. With its very clean ambiance and excellent service, visitors are impressed by the overall dining experience.

The food at Gr8 Bites is both fast and hot, ensuring that customers are satisfied. Additionally, the coffee receives positive reviews, with people saying that it is surprisingly good for a non-coffee shop. Furthermore, reviewers highly recommend Gr8 Bites for its fresh and delicious food, reasonable prices, and family-friendly atmosphere.

Despite its appearance as an old-fashioned ice cream shop, the restaurant exceeds expectations, and guests praise the efficient and friendly server named Ryan.

---

Sno Cones by Chris is a local restaurant worth visiting on Hilton Head Island. People say that Chris, the owner, is such a nice guy and the Sno Cones are amazing. Visitors come back year after year when they visit the area. While there was a water main break recently, Chris is currently running the business from outside his shop so guests can't see the Legos inside, but they have mentioned that the displays are awesome and hopefully didn't get damaged.

This unique restaurant offers a delightful experience, as there are many cool Lego creations in the shop that mesmerize children, like the Statue of Liberty, turtle, and Super Mario and Luigi. Aside from the Lego displays, guests love the wide variety of unique flavors to choose from, perfect for cooling off on a hot summer day.

Guests have spent around 40 minutes in awe of the Lego creations and their favorite characters, including a peanut butter jelly banana that dances! They appreciate Chris's personable nature and are often inspired by his love and passion for what he does.

If you're looking for an immersive and delicious experience, it's definitely worth checking out Chris' Sno Cones on Hilton Head Island.

---

Located in Hilton Head Island, Frosty Dog Cafe is a place worth visiting if you are looking for the best milkshake in town. Guests have raved about the exceptional customer service provided by the gentleman taking their orders. He goes above and beyond to ensure that all their needs are met and leaves a lasting impression.

Visitors have praised the hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious food served at this restaurant. Whether you're in the mood for chicken tenders and fries or a mouthwatering milkshake, Frosty Dog Cafe delivers outstanding taste and quality. With multiple check-ins during the meal to ensure satisfaction, the friendly and attentive service adds to the overall dining experience.

Don't miss out on this gem if you find yourself by the beach in Hilton Head Island.

---

Located in Hilton Head Island, Nonna Marie's Gelato & Coffee Bar is a cafe worth visiting for their delectable milkshakes. People say that the owner of this place is super informed and helpful, making it a perfect spot for anyone with gluten allergies as they are well-informed about it.

Their incredible cones, wrapped in white paper for a clean eating experience, make it easier for guests to enjoy their delicious treats without any mess. Visitors rave about the lavender cone, which is a favorite among many. With an extensive selection of flavors, including Pear with Fig, Mystical Unicorn, and Tiramisu, Nonna Marie's Gelato & Coffee Bar offers unique and interesting options that guests love.

Additionally, guests cannot resist meeting Chai, the café's adorable pooch. Whether you are in the mood for coffee or gelato, Nonna Marie's is a must-visit place where you can find a wide array of flavors and even various flavors of waffle cones.

---