Searching for the best Mexican dining experience on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina? Look no further. In this article, we have curated a list of the top 9 flavorful spots that are sure to satisfy your cravings for authentic Mexican cuisine. From traditional favorites to innovative creations, these restaurants offer a diverse range of delicious dishes that will transport your taste buds to Mexico.
Join us as we explore Hilton Head Island's vibrant culinary scene, featuring beloved establishments such as Fiesta Fresh Mexican Grill, Java Burrito Company, and Jesse's Island Food Truck. Get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the best Mexican restaurants on Hilton Head Island.
Jump to places
- Blue Laguna Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Amigos Cafe Y Cantina
- Cabritos Mexican Restaurant
- Fiesta Fresh Mexican Grill
- Mi Tierra Mexican Restaurant Hilton Head
- Holy Tequila Mexican Kitchen
- Tio's Latin American Kitchen
- La sureña
- San Miguel's Mexican
Blue Laguna Mexican Grill & Cantina is a popular spot for Mexican cuisine in Hilton Head Island. According to guests, the food at Blue Laguna is known for its flavorful and authentic taste, making it stand out from other Mexican restaurants on the island.
Despite lacking a waterfront location, the restaurant more than compensates with its high-quality dishes. One reviewer mentioned their positive experience in November 2020 and how they've been planning to return ever since, impressed by the food compared to other establishments.
Another reviewer appreciated the cleanliness and reasonable prices, mentioning that the Blue Margherita had a refreshing taste similar to a mojito. The service was described as fast and courteous, perhaps even slightly too quick as guests were in and out in less than 45 minutes.
Additionally, patrons enjoyed the live music provided by a talented musician. Although there were some menu discrepancies, overall, guests had a pleasant dining experience at Blue Laguna Mexican Grill & Cantina.
Blue Laguna Mexican Grill & Cantina Full Review
Amigos Cafe Y Cantina is a local spot worth visiting for its delicious food and fabulous service. Despite its small size and no-frills atmosphere, guests rave about the quality and taste of the Mexican plates served here. Visitors are pleasantly surprised by the friendly staff who are accommodating, even with custom orders.
The option to dine both indoors and outdoors adds to the casual and laid-back vibe. The raspberry lemonade receives high praise for its refreshing taste. One reviewer specifically mentions their enjoyment of the pollo asado tacos, which they describe as being a nice option for tacos.
Another reviewer, who had not visited in ten years due to relocation, was thrilled to find that very little had changed, even with new ownership. They highly recommend the BBQ Chicken Salad and describe the burrito as the biggest on the island. In fact, they humorously express how the burrito could potentially sink Capt.
Chip Michalove's fishing. Amigos Cafe Y Cantina is truly a hidden gem for those seeking authentic Mexican cuisine in Hilton Head Island.
Cabritos Mexican Restaurant is a local gem that is worth visiting on Hilton Head Island. Visitors say it offers an authentic Mexican dining experience, with a seemingly endless array of mouthwatering tacos to choose from. The restaurant has been praised for its unique ordering system, which may be a bit daunting for first-time guests, but is well worth the effort.
Guests can customize their tacos by adding toppings from a tray that includes onions, cilantro, limes, pineapple, and an array of flavorful hot sauces. For those who prefer something a little heartier, the burritos at Cabritos are highly recommended, known for their generous portions.
Apart from the delicious food, guests have also complimented the restaurant's attentive and friendly service. So if you're looking for an authentic Mexican feast in Hilton Head Island, Cabritos is the place to go.
Fiesta Fresh Mexican Grill is a local counter-serve chain that offers tacos, tortas, burritos, and other Mexican favorites in a casual space. Visitors say that this restaurant is worth a visit for several reasons. Firstly, the staff is described as warm and friendly, providing excellent customer service.
Guests also mentioned that the restaurant is extremely clean and there is no wait time. The food at Fiesta Fresh is highly praised for its delicious and authentic taste, with one reviewer mentioning that their order was prepared immediately as they spoke.
Another reviewer was initially unimpressed until they tasted the food, which quickly became a new favorite. The prices at this restaurant are also deemed reasonable. Additionally, the quality of the guacamole is seen as a measure of a Mexican restaurant's excellence and Fiesta Fresh makes the list of royalty in that regard.
Finally, the quantity of food and overall value for money is regarded as spot on, making it a diamond in the rough on Hilton Head Island.
Fiesta Fresh Mexican Grill Full Review
Mi Tierra Mexican Restaurant in Hilton Head Island is worth visiting for a taste of traditional Mexican eats in a vibrant cantina adorned with colorful folk art. People say that the food at Mi Tierra is simply amazing, with a range of dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving.
While some guests mention that the prices may be a little higher than expected, they still consider it the best dining experience during their stay on Hilton Head Island. Alongside the incredible food, Mi Tierra prides itself on providing excellent service, even when the restaurant is busy.
Visitors appreciate the friendly and attentive servers who make sure their glasses are always full. Although one reviewer regretted not taking pictures to capture the deliciousness of their meal, they enthusiastically declare their intention to return to Mi Tierra Mexican Restaurant in the future.
Mi Tierra Mexican Restaurant Hilton Head Full Review
Holy Tequila Mexican Kitchen is a stylish and bustling restaurant that offers modern Mexican fare and delicious cocktails. People say that the food at Holy Tequila is great and comes out in about 9 minutes, ensuring a quick and satisfying dining experience.
One guest highly recommends trying their pitcher of the Mejor Margaritas, stating that it was top-notch. The service at Holy Tequila is exceptional, with Torin being praised for his great personality and excellent knowledge of the food, area, and menu.
Visitors were particularly impressed by Torin's recommendation of the Steak Nachos, which are served on a cookie sheet and boast both generous portions and mouthwatering flavors. Another guest raves about their overall experience, describing the service as 5-star and the food as superb.
The outstanding adult drinks and live music further add to the enjoyable atmosphere. Holy Tequila Mexican Kitchen is a place worth visiting, and many guests vow to return year after year.
Holy Tequila Mexican Kitchen Full Review
Tio's Latin American Kitchen is worth visiting for those craving Mexican cuisine on Hilton Head Island. Guests have praised the solid service and quality of food, with one visitor mentioning their satisfying experience with the seafood burrito and Caesar salad topped with blackened shrimp.
The restaurant offers a vibrant and family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for a memorable meal. A unique feature that guests appreciate is the open kitchen, where they can witness the chef preparing fresh food. Tio's also caters to families, providing plenty of options for kids.
Additionally, the establishment's charming decor adds to the homely feeling, with each table having its own distinct style. While some reviewers have mentioned minor issues with cleanliness and staff, the overall experience at Tio's Latin American Kitchen remains positive and enjoyable.
Tio's Latin American Kitchen Full Review
La Sureña is a hidden gem on the island of Hilton Head. Guests rave about the impressive presentation and quality of their food. People say that the ingredients are fresh and the flavors are incredibly tasty. It is highly recommended to give this place a try if you are looking for real authentic Mexican cuisine.
Visitors appreciate that La Sureña stands out from the commercial places that claim to serve Mexican food but don't match up to the real deal. With its great taste and authenticity, it is no wonder that guests express their intention to return to this restaurant multiple times.
So, if you're craving genuine Mexican flavors during your visit to Hilton Head Island, make sure to check out La Sureña.
San Miguel's Mexican is a laid-back festive joint that offers an incredible dining experience. Visitors rave about the mouthwatering food, with one guest mentioning how they could have simply made a meal out of the salsa and chips alone. The Arroz Con Pollo, a delightful dish featuring chicken fajitas over rice with cheese, earns high praise for its deliciousness.
Service is also impeccable, as guests describe the staff as excellent and note the establishment's ability to craft a pretty good margarita. Apart from the delectable food and outstanding service, San Miguel's also boasts a picturesque location overlooking the marina.
Reviewers appreciate the prompt seating and attentive, kind waitstaff who ensure a pleasant dining experience. While some guests found the ground beef items to be underwhelming, the restaurant's other offerings receive glowing reviews. With its fun atmosphere, prime waterfront location, and delectable offerings, San Miguel's Mexican is a must-visit for anyone seeking an enjoyable Mexican dining experience in Hilton Head Island, SC.
